I remember striking up a friendship with someone who seemed almost too kind.
He always had a compliment ready, frequently offered little favors, and insisted he had my best interests at heart.
At first, I thought I’d finally found a supportive person who wanted to help me grow, both personally and professionally.
But eventually, I noticed something off: I felt obligated to let him influence my decisions, even the small ones. I recognized that underneath the helpful exterior was someone who liked to be in control, and it felt suffocating.
That experience got me interested in how “nice” narcissists operate.
Unlike the more obvious narcissist who demands attention, the nice kind can be subtle and disarming.
They often hide their true motives behind compliments or caring gestures. You might think you’re making a genuine connection, but the reality is that they’re carefully reeling you in.
In this post, I’ll share seven common phrases someone with these traits might use to gain trust and control.
If you’ve ever felt uneasy in a relationship that seems friendly on the surface, these could be red flags.
1. “I just want what’s best for you.”
On the surface, there’s nothing wrong with wanting the best for someone else.
Genuine friends and mentors do express concern for your well-being.
The difference is how frequently this phrase shows up and in what context.
A controlling person might repeat these words to override your instincts.
Whenever you have a different opinion or choice in mind, they’ll trot out the idea that they’re just looking out for you.
Over time, you might begin to second-guess yourself, wondering if you’re being ungrateful or foolish for ignoring such “supportive” advice.
According to psychology, individuals with narcissistic tendencies often mask their self-serving intentions as benevolence.
They tell you they’re doing it all for you, making you feel indebted and ignoring the reality that they’re mainly seeking to shape your actions in ways that benefit them.
Whenever someone insists a bit too much on wanting the best for you, pause and think: Are they respecting your personal boundaries? Do they get upset if you don’t take their suggestions? A truly caring person will still respect your ability to decide for yourself.
2. “You can trust me; I’m always looking out for you.”
Trust is crucial in any meaningful relationship. Still, if someone keeps demanding your trust without demonstrating trustworthiness in tangible ways, that’s a signal to look deeper.
A “nice” narcissist might say this repeatedly to create an illusion of safety.
They’ll pepper conversations with, “Don’t worry, I’ll handle it,” or “You have nothing to fear with me,” even if you never expressed concern in the first place.
When trust is natural, it doesn’t require constant reassurance.
It also doesn’t come with strings attached.
If the person goes on to push you into sharing your secrets, or they expect you to defer decisions to them because they’re “always looking out for you,” it’s time to examine what they’re really gaining from it.
Healthy trust means give-and-take.
You rely on each other without feeling pressured.
But a subtle manipulator might turn the concept of trust into a tool for control.
They might expect you to follow their lead blindly because “trust me” becomes a shield they hide behind whenever you question them.
3. “I’m only saying this because I care.”
I’ve had someone say this before sending a pointed critique my way.
Initially, I was grateful; I appreciated that they cared enough to share tough feedback.
But then, it became a pattern. Every other day, another “harsh truth” followed by “I’m only saying this because I care about you.” Their tone was rarely empathetic; it felt more like an excuse to pick apart what I was doing.
Caring feedback doesn’t leave you feeling small or guilty for not following someone else’s opinion.
If someone’s so-called supportive words consistently make you feel inadequate, check if this person is truly invested in your growth or just trying to shape you in a way that serves their ego.
Constructive criticism usually includes understanding and solutions. If all you get is a barrage of negativity with a quick “I’m saying this because I love you,” it might be more about control than care.
4. “You’re so special—no one else gets me like you do.”
Who doesn’t want to feel special? Everyone craves that moment when someone says, “I’ve never connected with anyone the way I connect with you.”
But manipulative individuals know that lavishing you with flattering statements can lower your guard. A “nice” narcissist might bring you into their confidence, praising your uniqueness, intelligence, or empathy.
It feels wonderful, and you start thinking you’ve found a genuine connection.
However, notice how quickly the dynamic shifts when you stop playing along.
They might withdraw affection or blame you for “not understanding” them anymore.
It’s a form of love-bombing, commonly discussed in relationship articles on sites like Psychology Today, where sudden, intense praise is used to form an emotional bond. Once they have your trust and admiration, they can more easily steer you in directions that serve them.
Real friendship or partnership won’t hinge on constant validation. Sure, compliments and feeling special can be part of healthy relationships, but they aren’t the currency through which the entire bond is sustained.
If someone repeatedly reminds you how you’re the “only” one who understands them, it may be a form of emotional dependence that benefits them more than you.
5. “I need you to be honest with me (when I ask).”
On the face of it, honesty is a virtue we all value. But this phrase often comes with an unspoken catch: you have to be honest when the “nice” narcissist wants information.
They might not extend the same honesty in return. Instead, they use your open communication to gather intel about your insecurities, fears, or private thoughts.
A subtle manipulator might say this at precisely the moment they sense you’re holding back.
They’ll even project a sense of wounded trust: “I thought we were closer than that. Why can’t you be honest with me?” Before you know it, you’re spilling your thoughts and feelings while they share very little. When you do express needs or boundaries, they might find a way to twist your own words to their advantage.
Pay attention to whether there’s mutual vulnerability. Are they also open with you? Do they give you the same courtesy of honesty without turning it against you?
A healthy relationship is built on a two-way street of trust.
6. “I would never hurt you; you know that, right?”
Sometimes, this phrase sounds incredibly reassuring—until you see how it’s used in context.
A manipulator may offer this statement preemptively, even when you haven’t implied they’d hurt you.
It can pop up during discussions about what you want out of a friendship, a work partnership, or a romantic relationship.
They insert it to suggest, “I’m harmless and only here to support you, so let’s move on.”
Yet, words mean little without actions to back them up. If this individual uses guilt, silent treatment, or subtle forms of gaslighting, they are causing harm—even if they claim they never intend to.
A person’s repeated promises to not hurt you can paradoxically become a form of emotional pressure.
They want you to set aside your concerns, lower your guard, and place complete faith in them.
When you hear this phrase, think carefully: why do they need to reassure me of this? Have they done something to betray my trust in the past? If their track record is marked by manipulative behavior, this phrase is less of a comfort and more of a diversion.
7. “We should keep this between us.”
Secrecy is a powerful tool for manipulation.
It isolates you from potential support systems and prevents you from receiving outside perspectives that might help you see the bigger picture. A “nice” narcissist might repeatedly insist on privacy because they don’t want anyone else challenging their narrative.
If they can keep you from confiding in friends, family, or colleagues, they can guide your thoughts unchecked.
They might share something that feels personal, making you promise not to disclose it, and you respond in kind with your own secrets.
Now you’re both bound by confidentiality.
But if the other person starts to use that information against you—or threatens to reveal a personal detail if you don’t comply with their requests—then you’re dealing with a clear case of control.
In a healthy relationship, boundaries around privacy are respected, but not weaponized.
You can share sensitive details knowing the other person isn’t using it as collateral.
Wrapping up
We all want trusting, supportive relationships.
But genuine support never demands your constant obedience, nor does it make you feel guilty for having your own opinions.
The best protection is self-awareness. When you hear phrases that sound sweet but leave you uneasy, listen to that intuition.
Healthy relationships respect boundaries, encourage mutual growth, and foster genuine emotional security.
Anyone who truly cares about you will stand by your decisions even when they differ from theirs—and they won’t make you feel indebted for it.
Feeling stuck in self-doubt?
Stop trying to fix yourself and start embracing who you are. Join the free 7-day self-discovery challenge and learn how to transform negative emotions into personal growth.
