We’ve all been there – in the middle of a heated discussion when suddenly, the volume starts to rise.
The other person’s voice reaches an uncomfortable level, as if the amplification of their words will somehow make their argument more valid.
But why do people shout when they feel they’re losing an argument?
Psychology offers some insights. Turns out, these volume-enhancers often share a few common traits.
In this article, we’ll delve into the seven traits that are usually displayed by people who raise their voice during a disagreement.
This isn’t just about understanding human behavior, though.
It’s about equipping yourself with the knowledge to navigate these interactions effectively and create a healthier, more respectful communication environment within your team.
Because let’s face it – nobody likes a shouting match.
1) Insecurity often leads to loudness
We’ve all seen this play out. Suddenly, the volume goes up and the calm discussion turns into a shouting match. But what’s the underlying reason for this reaction?
Psychologists suggest that it could be a sign of insecurity.
When someone feels cornered or unable to defend their point of view with logical arguments, they might resort to raising their voice in an attempt to regain control or assert dominance.
When people are unsure about their stance in an argument, they may compensate by speaking louder.
Understanding this trait is more than just about dealing with raised voices. It’s about recognizing the underlying insecurities that may be driving it.
This could help you approach discussions with empathy and patience, promoting a culture of respect and understanding within your team.
2) A desire for control can amplify volume
I remember very clearly a disagreement I had with a colleague last year.
We were debating on the best strategy to implement for a new project, and as we delved deeper into the discussion, I noticed his voice steadily rising.
It was clear that he felt his point of view was losing ground, and the volume seemed to be his way of trying to regain control of the argument.
This behavior aligns with what psychologists term as dominance behavior. When people feel they are losing control or power in a situation, they may resort to raising their voice as a means of asserting dominance or authority.
Dr. Carl Jung, a famous Swiss psychiatrist and psychoanalyst once said: “Where love rules, there is no will to power, and where power predominates, there love is lacking. The one is the shadow of the other.”
In this context, the desire for control or power can overshadow effective communication and lead to increased volume during disagreements.
Reflecting on this personal experience has made me more aware of how our emotions can influence our reactions during conflicts.
It’s helped me approach disagreements with an understanding that sometimes, the rise in volume may just be a reflection of a person’s need for control.
3) Feelings of inadequacy can trigger loud reactions
Have you ever felt inadequate in a situation? It’s a deeply unsettling feeling, isn’t it?
I’ve had moments where I’ve felt my arguments weren’t strong enough or my knowledge wasn’t sufficient. And in those moments, I’ve noticed a temptation to raise my voice, projecting confidence I didn’t feel.
This reaction is not uncommon. Psychologists highlight that feelings of inadequacy can sometimes trigger louder reactions during disagreements.
It’s as if the increased volume is compensating for the perceived lack of substance or validity in one’s arguments.
Dr. Abraham Maslow, one of the most renowned psychologists of the 20th century, once said: “What is necessary to change a person is to change his awareness of himself.”
Recognizing this trait in ourselves can be a powerful step towards change.
Being honest about our feelings of inadequacy can help us navigate discussions more effectively.
And when we sense this trait in others, we can strive to foster an environment where everyone feels heard and valued, regardless of the volume of their voice.
4) Fear of confrontation can lead to vocal escalation
It might seem counterintuitive, but sometimes, the people who raise their voices in disagreements are actually the ones who fear confrontation the most.
It’s a sort of defense mechanism – they’re hoping that by getting louder, they can intimidate the other party into backing down and thus avoid a full-blown argument.
This interesting correlation was highlighted in a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
The researchers found that individuals with high levels of conflict avoidance were more likely to engage in aggressive behavior, including raising their voice, during disagreements.
This finding underscores the importance of fostering open and respectful communication within our teams.
By creating an environment where individuals feel safe expressing their opinions without fear of confrontation, we can help mitigate these vocal escalations and promote healthier discussions.
5) Stress can turn up the volume
Let’s face it, we’ve all had those days where everything seems to be going wrong, and our stress levels are through the roof.
I’ve noticed that on such days, my patience wears thin more easily, and I tend to react more strongly to disagreements.
Psychologists agree that stress can often be a contributing factor to raised voices during arguments. When we’re stressed, our patience and tolerance levels decrease, making us more prone to vocal escalations.
The renowned psychologist Dr. Hans Selye once said: “It’s not stress that kills us, it is our reaction to it.”
Recognizing the role that stress plays in our reactions can help us manage our responses during disagreements.
Next time you find yourself in a heated discussion, take a moment to assess your stress levels. You might find that taking a few deep breaths or stepping away for a moment can help keep the volume down.
6) A need for validation can increase the decibels
Ironically, those who shout the loudest during disagreements may be those who are seeking validation the most. They may raise their voice in an attempt to be heard and acknowledged.
Psychologists suggest that a deep-seated need for validation can sometimes manifest in louder voices during disagreements. It’s as if the increased volume is a plea for recognition and understanding.
Instead of reacting negatively to increased volumes, we can see it as an opportunity to validate the other person’s feelings and perspectives, fostering a more understanding and collaborative environment.
7) Lack of emotional intelligence may cause a volume spike
Lastly, those who raise their voice during arguments may do so due to a lack of emotional intelligence. They may struggle to control their emotions, leading to vocal escalations.
As Dr. Daniel Goleman, the author of “Emotional Intelligence,” states: “Emotional self-control— delaying gratification and stifling impulsiveness— underlies accomplishment of every sort.”
Recognizing this trait can lead us towards fostering emotional intelligence within our teams, promoting healthier and more productive discussions.
Final reflections
Human behavior is a complex tapestry, woven with threads of emotions, insecurities, and desires. Our reactions during conflicts, including the tendency to raise our voices, are a part of this intricate design.
Understanding these patterns gives us more than just knowledge. It offers us a mirror to reflect on our own behaviors and triggers.
It equips us with the tools to foster a healthier communication environment within our teams and personal relationships.
Next time you find yourself in a heated discussion, remember these traits.
Recognize the insecurities, the fear of confrontation, the need for validation. Notice the stressors and the desire for control. Understand the role of emotional intelligence.
Remember that behind every raised voice is a story – a narrative shaped by individual experiences and perceptions.
By understanding these narratives, we can approach disagreements with empathy and patience, creating space for productive dialogue instead of shouting matches.
Because when we understand why we raise our voices, we can begin to change how we communicate – one conversation at a time.
Feeling stuck in self-doubt?
Stop trying to fix yourself and start embracing who you are. Join the free 7-day self-discovery challenge and learn how to transform negative emotions into personal growth.
