It’s one of those things that sneaks up on you.
You scroll, you click, you like, and before you know it, the content showing up in your feed feels… weirdly personal. Almost like it was made just for you.
At first, it seems harmless—even helpful. But then certain ideas start repeating over and over. You notice yourself thinking differently about things, reacting more strongly than you used to, or even making decisions based on what keeps popping up on your screen.
It doesn’t happen overnight, and that’s what makes it tricky. The algorithm isn’t just recommending content—it’s shaping the way you think without you even realizing it.
Here’s how to tell if that’s happening to you and why psychology says it’s worth paying attention to.
1) You start believing that what you see is all there is
The algorithm is designed to give you more of what you engage with. The more you click, the more it reinforces what it thinks you want to see.
At first, this seems helpful—it saves time by filtering out content that doesn’t interest you. But over time, it can create a bubble where everything you see confirms what you already think.
You stop coming across different perspectives. It starts feeling like everyone agrees with you, and anything outside of that feels strange or even wrong.
Psychologists call this the “availability heuristic“—when the information that’s most easily available to us starts shaping our beliefs about reality.
And when your feed is carefully curated by an algorithm, it’s easy to mistake what’s showing up for what’s actually true.
2) You feel anxious or defensive when you see something that challenges your views
When everything in your feed lines up with what you already believe, anything that contradicts it can feel uncomfortable. Instead of curiosity, you feel frustration. Instead of considering a different perspective, you scroll past it—or worse, get angry.
I remember realizing this about myself when I came across an article that completely opposed my opinion on a business trend I had followed for years.
My immediate reaction wasn’t to read it with an open mind—it was to dismiss it. I caught myself thinking, “They just don’t get it,” without even giving the argument a chance.
That was when I knew something had shifted. The algorithm had fed me so much of the same perspective that any challenge to it felt like an attack rather than an opportunity to learn.
3) Your opinions start feeling like absolute truth
Mark Twain once said, “It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It’s what you know for sure that just ain’t so.”
When an algorithm keeps reinforcing the same ideas, it becomes easy to mistake repetition for truth. The more often we hear something, the more likely we are to believe it—whether it’s accurate or not. Psychologists call this the “illusory truth effect.”
You might notice yourself becoming more certain about things you never really questioned before. Instead of seeing your opinions as perspectives, they start feeling like undeniable facts.
And when something feels like an absolute truth, there’s no reason to keep learning, questioning, or growing.
4) You mistake engagement for importance
The algorithm doesn’t show you what’s most important—it shows you what’s most likely to keep you on the platform.
Content that sparks strong emotions, whether positive or negative, tends to get prioritized because it leads to more clicks, comments, and shares.
This can make the world feel more extreme than it actually is. The loudest, most dramatic voices rise to the top, while more balanced or nuanced discussions get buried.
Over time, it starts to seem like the most talked-about topics are the most important ones, even if they don’t really affect your life or business in any meaningful way.
What gets the most engagement isn’t always what deserves the most attention. But when an algorithm decides what you see, it can be hard to tell the difference.
5) You catch yourself thinking in viral soundbites
When you’re exposed to the same types of content repeatedly, it doesn’t just influence what you believe—it shapes how you think. Ideas get compressed into quick, catchy phrases designed to be shared, liked, and repeated.
You might notice yourself arguing in short, oversimplified statements instead of engaging in deeper discussions. Complex issues start feeling black and white. The more you absorb these bite-sized thoughts, the harder it becomes to think beyond them.
Real understanding takes more than a headline or a 30-second clip. But when an algorithm prioritizes what’s quick and engaging over what’s thoughtful and deep, it can make slow, critical thinking feel like too much effort.
6) You feel like the other side is completely irrational
When your feed is filled with content that reinforces your views, it becomes easy to assume that anyone who disagrees just doesn’t get it.
Instead of seeing opposing perspectives as coming from thoughtful, reasonable people with different experiences, they start to seem ridiculous—or even dangerous.
The algorithm amplifies this by often showing the most extreme or exaggerated versions of opposing viewpoints, making them easier to dismiss.
Over time, this creates an “us vs. them” mindset where it feels like there’s no middle ground. But in reality, most people are more nuanced than their online caricatures—and most issues are more complex than the algorithm makes them seem.
7) Your thoughts start mirroring the content you consume
What you see every day doesn’t just influence your opinions—it starts shaping your inner dialogue. The phrases, arguments, and emotions you absorb online can quietly become the way you process the world around you.
I caught myself realizing this when I was frustrated about a business challenge and my first thought was almost word-for-word something I had seen in a viral post earlier that week.
It wasn’t even an idea I had fully thought through—I had just absorbed it from repeated exposure.
When the algorithm feeds you the same themes over and over, they don’t just stay on your screen. They become part of how you think, react, and make decisions without you even noticing.
8) You struggle to disconnect—even when you want to
The algorithm isn’t just shaping what you think—it’s shaping how much time you spend thinking about it.
It’s designed to keep you scrolling, always offering another post, another video, another discussion that feels too relevant to ignore. Even when you know you should step away, there’s this pull to stay just a little longer.
Psychologists call this “variable reward reinforcement“—the same principle that makes slot machines addictive. The next piece of content might be the most interesting, the most validating, the most entertaining yet.
And before you know it, your free time, your focus, even your peace of mind are being dictated by a system designed to never let you go.
The bottom line
If you recognize these patterns in your own life, you’re not alone. Algorithms are built to capture attention, influence behavior, and keep us engaged—often without us realizing it.
The good news is that awareness gives you back control. Start paying attention to what shows up in your feed and how it makes you feel.
Challenge yourself to seek out different perspectives, think beyond viral soundbites, and question whether the loudest voices are really the most important.
Being intentional about what you consume helps break this cycle.
Take back your ability to think freely. Read outside your algorithm’s recommendations. Engage with ideas that challenge you.
And most importantly, step away when you need to—because the most valuable thoughts are often the ones that happen offline.
Feeling stuck in self-doubt?
Stop trying to fix yourself and start embracing who you are. Join the free 7-day self-discovery challenge and learn how to transform negative emotions into personal growth.
